Admittedly, Atomic Buffalo Turd does not sound like an appealing appetizer, and explaining the name is no joy either. Around our house, we often just call these badboys stuffed peppers. I don’t particularly like hearing my little girl run around talking about buffalo turds, so stuffed peppers it is.
Whatever you want to call them, ABT’s are a hearty way to bring a little bbq wow factor to any party. With an unimaginable number of flavorful filling options, you can tailor these treats to any event.
What I’m going to give you is my goto ABT. The types of cheese may vary from cook to cook, but the overall flavor is usually pretty similar. For me, there are three constants to my ABT’s: Peppers, bacon, and cream cheese. After that, it’s wide open.
The peppers I use depend on the mood that day. I like simple jalapenos, but they vary so widely in heat, they can be a bit unpredictable. What I use most often are just little sweet peppers. They are similar in shape and size to jalapenos, but have little to no heat whatsoever. Just sweet pepper flavor. My taste in ABT’s tends to drift to the sweet side. Feel free to tailor your recipe to go a little more savory if you like. It’s hard to mess these up
Please allow me to share one of my all time favorites with you.
Italian Sausage and 3 cheese stuffed ABT’s.
Ingredients:
- Block of cream cheese
- 1 cup smoked gouda, finely grated
- 1 cup mozzarella, finely grated
- 20 or so jalapeno or sweet peppers, sliced in half lengthwise, seeded and cored
- 3/4lb of bulk italian sausage, cooked and broken down to very small pieces. (turkery or pork)
- 1 package bacon, cut in half (so you get twice as many pieces, half as long.)
- few tablespoons of your favorite bbq sauce
In a medium bowl, mix the three cheeses and bbq sauce into a big gloppy mess.
Put a layer of cheese into each pepper. I usually just put a little blob in, then run it down the pepper with my thumb. (By the way, I very much recommend latex or nitrile gloves for working with Jalepenos.
Add a layer of italian sausage, and press into the cheese mixture.
Wrap the whole thing with a half slice of bacon, and stab it with a toothpick. I like to push the toothpick through the bottom, so it creates a little stick to put between the grill grates, and keep the pepper from rolling over during cooking.
Put the whole mess of peppers on indirect heat until the bacon is cooked. If you smoke these at 225, this will probably be about an hour.
I wish I could provide you better pictures of the finished product, but usually, by the time they are done, I’m so ready to chow down, pictures wind up playing second fiddle to my belly!
enjoy!
Another Tip: If you are just using cream cheese, you can put all the cheese into a plastic baggy, cut the tip off the baggy and pipe the cheese into the peppers.













